Comic Browser:

#1
#2
#3
#4
Selector

Thor: Heaven and Earth #1

Jun 2011
Paul Jenkins, Ariel Olivetti

Story Name:

The Day Before Winter


Synopsis

Thor: Heaven and Earth #1 synopsis by Peter Silvestro
Rating: 3 stars

Tyr and Vidar stand on the battlements of Asgard, watching an invading army led by a frost giant approaching the gates and wondering if this is Ragnarök. At the main gates, Hildegarde and others prepare for battle as the ram batters the gate. Thor persuades the Winter God who guards the imprisoned Loki to allow him access to the prisoner. Thor frees Loki and asks him if this is Ragnarök. Loki says no because then he would be leading it. Thor thinks Loki is lying and beats him to force him to tell the truth, even holding his head underwater. Loki suggests that Thor is angry not because Loki is lying but because Loki claims that the fall of Asgard will have a beneficial outcome….

Odin summons Tiki, God of Stone, Asgard’s architect, to ask about a fissure spreading through the city. Tikis says it will split Asgard and nothing can stop it….

Thor insists that no good can come of Asgard’s fall just as no good can come of Loki’s lies. Loki then rattles off several scenarios in which good does come from lies, many being to avoid hurting feelings, or as a strategy in war, or to protect someone, even noting that Thor’s claims to love Loki are lies. Everything has a purpose….

As the city continues to split in two, Thor ties Loki between two pillars straddling the fissure. Loki tells Thor he is just lying to himself. Thor goes outside and examines the fissure, finding a small plant growing within….   



 

Review / Commentaries


Thor: Heaven and Earth #1 Review by (October 9, 2024)

Review: Or, “The Thunder God is the Thug.” The first entry in this offbeat miniseries portrays Thor as a big dumb thug who beats his confusion and insecurity out of a smaller, weaker Loki. And all Loki is trying to say is that perhaps some good can result from the fall of Asgard. And the brutish portrayal of Thor is aided and abetted by the heavy-handed art. Loki’s list of beneficial lies would make a nice syllabus for a discussion of morality and truth. That gets the issue an extra half star for the otherwise ponderous and repetitive talkfest.

Comments: Issue likely takes place during THOR Vol. 2 #39 before page 18.



> Thor: Heaven and Earth comic book info and issue index

Elektra

Excelsioring your collection:
Kotobukiya Marvel Universe: Thor The Bronze Age ARTFX Statue, Multicolor
Holy smokes, Batman!
(The Boy Wonder)

Ariel Olivetti
Ariel Olivetti
Ariel Olivetti
Ariel Olivetti (Cover Penciler)
Ariel Olivetti (Cover Inker)
Ariel Olivetti (Cover Colorist)
Additional Credits
Letterer: Dave Sharpe.

Characters

Listed in Alphabetical Order.

Hildegarde
Hildegarde

(Hildegarde)
Loki
Loki

(Loki Laufeyson)
Thor
Thor

(Odinson)

Plus: Vidar Giant’s-Child.