Previous Page   Next Page
#135
#136
#137
#138
#139
#140
#141
#142
#143
#144
#145
#146
#147
#148
#149
#150
#151
#152
Selector

New Defenders, The (1983 series) #140

Feb 1985 on-sale: Sep 18, 1984

Peter Gillis
writer
 |  Don Perlin
penciler

New Defenders, The (1983 series) #140 cover

Story Name:

The Heartbreak Kid!


Synopsis

New Defenders, The (1983 series) #140 synopsis by reviewer Peter Silvestro
Rating: 3 stars

Vera Cantor receives a present in the mail: a pair of flowers and a love poem from Hank “The Beast” McCoy but it only makes her angry. She is fed up that her putative boyfriend keeps breaking dates, chasing other women, and lately moving to New Mexico without telling her. Yet looking at the flowers and poem soften her heart and she forgives him….

At the Defenders’ mountain HQ, Moondragon, having been freed of her headband last issue, has adopted a black-and-white outfit with a cape to reflect her changed status. Gargoyle is having trouble eating while lacking a right hand; Moondragon gives him a psychic assist to demonstrate her new kinder nature which sees the value in even the most humble of beings (which Beast and Iceman find patronizing but they make a joke out of it)….

LEGO Marvel Dancing Groot
Excelsioring your collection

Later, Cloud visits Moondragon in her room, expressing her love for her teammate, whether as a girl or a boy. Moondragon tries to explain the attraction as a side effect of her psychic battles with her headband, which Cloud brushes off, asking if MD loves her. Moondragon hides behind the vague definition of love, regretting her words when Cloud departs….

In Abbottsford, a nearby small town, Daniel Shepard is in jail, accused of a dire deed which his father, the Sheriff, tries to understand, slapping his son over it. The boy responds that he did it because he hates his father. Later, Sheriff Shepard and his wife Louise receive a visit from Edna May Terry, Daniel’s victim, who wants to see the boy to try to understand what he did. Shepard takes her to the jailhouse where she asks Daniel why he did what he did to her and he responds it was because she was available and because she was a Negro, shocking her….

At the Aerie, Moondragon picks up psychic emanations from the incident and she alerts the others, telling them that she has detected a strange source of power and believes they should investigate it. Beast finds this description too vague too act on and refuses to go. Iceman chooses to stay behind too (later suggesting it’s because the gender-swapping Cloud gives him the creeps), and Gargoyle pleads his missing hand as a handicap. So the others (Moondragon, Angel, Valkyrie, and Cloud) take a jet to Abbottsford….

In a nearby farm, a cow gives birth but the result is a deformed man covered with sores and green slime, shocking the farmers…and then it rises up and kills them….

The Defenders half-team arrives in Abbottsford to discover a band of White Supremacists kicking up a ruckus by defending Danny Shepard as a victim of Black people’s political agenda; a Black man hurls a rock at the speaker and the Whites go to open fire but the Defenders swoop in to stop the violence with Moondragon manipulating everyone to be calm and peaceful….

At Danny’s trial, Edna May Terry takes the stand to describe how her student Danny approached her after class and [the implication is rape though they can’t say that in a Comics Code-approved story]. Danny takes the stand and calmly describes how he feels no remorse, that Miss Terry is worthless and deserved what happened to her, that evil happens everywhere and he would do it again, his only crime was being caught. An angry man in the courtroom, draws a gun and fires at Danny but Moondragon uses her power to halt the bullet in midair and then compels Danny to tell the truth—that he wanted to break everyone’s heart. Moondragon then asks Miss Terry to explain what really happened in the classroom. This time she reveals that Danny forced her to recall her darkest secret—how she fell in love with a white man, bore his child and was then forced to give it up for adoption—and reliving the memory felt like rape to her. The big question now is why did Danny do it? He explains that he felt her deep heartbreak for the first time so that he knew he had t break the hearts of everyone in town so he could use his power to take it all away. And so with a wave of his hand Danny empties everyone in court of their sorrows, freeing them to be happy. And then he leaves. The Defenders ask why Moondragon doesn’t stop him; she replies that there is a lot of heartbreak in the world….

Back in the valley below Defenders HQ some strange plants grow tendrils that resemble human hands, all reaching for the Aerie….

AMAZING SPIDER-MAN EPIC COLLECTION: NINE LIVES HAS THE BLACK CAT
Excelsioring your collection


Characters
Good (or All)
ANGEL  
Angel
(Warren Worthington III)
BEAST  
Beast
(Hank McCoy)
GARGIC  
Gargoyle
(Isaac Christians)
ICEMAN  
Iceman
(Bobby Drake)
MOONDRAGON  
Moondragon
(Heather Douglas)
VALKYRIE  
Valkyrie
(Brunnhilda)
Plus: Vera Cantor.


> New Defenders, The (1983 series) comic book info and issue index



Marvel Legends Series Avengers 15-cm-Scale Marvel’s Tigra Figure
Excelsioring your collection

Main/1st Story Full Credits

Don Perlin
Kim DeMulder
Ken Feduniewicz
Mark Badger (Cover Penciler)
Kevin Nowlan (Cover Inker)
Unknown (Cover Colorist)
Additional Credits
Letterer: Janice Chiang.
Editor: Carl Potts. Editor-in-chief: Jim Shooter.



Review / Commentaries


reviewer
New Defenders, The (1983 series) #140 Review by (May 26, 2026)

Review: Another generic cover graces an odd issue here as it starts with two pages on Vera Cantor who hasn’t appeared in a while and won’t return for several more issues (See the Comments)…so what’s the emphasis for? And then the story switches to the New and Improved Moondragon, complete with new outfit. But she still clashes with Beast over nonsense while Gargoyle pleads a missing hand for exempting himself from the action despite his main powers not being in his fingers so why is he lying? Iceman is the strangest: it’s because he finds sexual minorities to be creepy viz. Cloud. More on her later, more on him later than that.

And then we come to the main story and is has a startlingly dark edge, talking about rape (in a veiled fashion), bigotry, racism, coming near to a mass murder on a town street. And its intensity is part of the point: Danny takes peoples’ pain and sorrow onto himself and cleanses the sufferers of them. The problem is that the writing isn’t very lucid. I had to read this multiple times and consult the Marvel Database to be sure of what was going on at the end. All of the meanness, sadness, and fear that is being expiated at the end tends to grow so intense that it overwhelms the final revelation. And it would have been nice to see Danny again sometime and not twenty years later in a tale set earlier than this one where Danny is overshadowed by Spider-Man.

Final Note: That mutant calf is a really creepy image. Enough to blank out the rest of the comic for us.

Comments: The story has no connection to the movie THE HEARTBREAK KID (1972) or its 2007 remake. First appearance of Daniel Shepard whose only subsequent appearance is in AMAZING FANTASY (2004) #15, where he meets Peter Parker. Ephraim Soles was first seen in his more monstrous form in issue #132. Gargoyle lost his hand in issue #137; not to worry, it’s growing back. Vera Cantor, in Marvel Comics since X-MEN #19 in 1966, her most recent appearance here was in DEFENDERS #122 and her next will be #149.





Thor

The Marvel Heroes Library is a fan Marvel Comics site
Version 14.14.12 (May 26, 2026 - VS22)

Copyright © 1997-2026 Julio Molina-Muscara (creator, webmaster)
Site content is a collective effort by the MHL team and Marvel aficionados

Characters are copyright © Marvel or their respective owners. All portions of this Marvel fansite that are subject to copyright are licensed under a creative commons attribution 3.0 unported license All rights reserved