Comic Browser:

#1
#2
#3
#4
#5
Selector

Red Skull #1: Review

Jul 2011
Greg Pak, Mirko Colak

Story Name:

[Red Skull: Incarnate Chapter 1]

Review & Comments

Rating:
3 stars

Red Skull #1 Review by (March 15, 2022)

Review: Dark and intense tale is well-written and ably illustrated, a look at the genesis of “Marvel’s most evil villain” (as Greg Pak puts it). Sadly, it fails in its stated purpose: Greg Pak states that it is to explain how a nation as advanced and cultured as Germany could “descend into the barbarism of the Nazi regime” and “how everyday people can so willingly embrace evil.” Yet that isn’t what we get in the story: we see little of everyday people in the series, all Nazis are portrayed as warped already, finding in the Nazi cause a license to be bullies and thugs. And Johann Schmidt certainly cannot be his example of an ordinary person. So Pak’s stated questions are never answered.

How about the secondary purpose, explaining the origin of the Red Skull, who, mind you, is never referred to as such, with the story ending before the beginnings of organized persecution of the Jewish people? Alas, that too falls short. According to the canonical account of the Red Skull’s origin as portrayed in TALES OF SUSPENSE #66, Johann Schmidt was an orphaned misfit whose bullying at the hands of society turned him bitter and hateful. Hitler saw this in his eyes and vowed to make him the perfect Nazi—which he did and the Red Skull is dedicated to carrying forward Hitler’s lust for power and domination. But Pak’s Schmidt is an opportunist, lacking the hatred Hitler saw, instead he joins whichever group allows him to be a bully. We never see Pak’s Schmidt embrace any particular ideology; this guy believes in nothing but getting ahead by any means necessary. This Schmidt would never continue Hitler’s dream after him. Instead he would likely becomes a Communist and support them with as much fervor as he did the Nazis. Much as I enjoy Greg Pak’s work on Hulk, I think this effort is a misfire.

Comments: Story title projected back from issue #3. Published in a collected edition as RED SKULL: INCARNATE. The quote on the front cover is by Frederick the Great and translates to "The strength of the state rests on the great men who are born to them at the right hour." (Thanks to the Marvel Database for this note.) Mention of a child-killer in Berlin is likely a reference to the classic German film M (1931). Includes an afterword by Greg Pak on how and why he came to write this book.





 

Synopsis / Summary / Plot

Red Skull #1 Synopsis by Peter Silvestro

1923: As the German economy is at its lowest point, the orphaned Johann Shmidt is in the Munich Home for Wayward Boys, managed by a brutal Director. His friend Dieter finds a stray puppy and Johann helps him hide it from the dog catcher and from the Director. Late one night, Johann goes downstairs but Dieter thinks he is going to tell the Director but he is getting food for the dog from the kitchen. Dieter ends up in the infirmary after another beating and Johann runs away. The Director follows him but they are stopped by a Nazi march on City Hall; the Director tells Johann these are the true German patriots. Gunfire breaks out; the Nazi leader is hustled to safety by his men. The Director forces Johann to stand firm but the boy runs away and jumps into the dog catcher’s truck. He asks to see how the dog catcher kills the dogs. The dog catcher stuns the dogs with a blow to the head with a club and then he cuts their throats with a knife. He hands Johann the club and knife and tells him to do the next one. Then he produces Dieter’s puppy but Johann can’t bring himself to harm the pup. The dog catcher congratulates him for still having some humanity, puts the pup in a pen with other dogs then leaves. The bigger dogs attack the puppy so Johann enters the pen and beats the big dogs brutally with the club. Afterward, he discovers the puppy is mortally wounded so he cuts its throat and leaves….




Mirko Colak
Mirko Colak
Matthew Wilson
David Aja (Cover Penciler)
David Aja (Cover Inker)
David Aja (Cover Colorist)
Letterer: Clayton Cowles.

Characters

Listed in Alphabetical Order.

Red Skull
Red Skull

(Johann Shmidt)



> Red Skull: Book info and issue index

Share This Page


Elektra