Previous Page   Next Page
#45
#46
#47
#48
#49
#50
#51
#52
#53
#54
#55
#56
#57
#58
#59
#60
#61
#62
#63
#64
#65
#66
#67
#68
Selector

Thor (1998 series) #50

Aug 2002 on-sale: Jun 5, 2002

Dan Jurgens
writer
 |  Tom Raney
penciler

Thor (1998 series) #50 cover

Story Name:

By Fire Born Part V of V


Synopsis

Thor (1998 series) #50 synopsis by reviewer Peter Silvestro
Rating: 4 stars

A prologue shows us the greatness of Asgard, especially under the wise rule of Odin until the day he fell in battle with Surtur. So Thor was chosen to mount the throne, with hopes of Asgard growing even greater. But the expectations of Thor were unreasonable so when a war against the Frost Giants, coming quickly after the war with Surtur, led to the deaths of numerous warriors, Thor was blamed and when Thor left that battle to go to Earth, he was seen to have abandoned his people. And then the battle with Desak the God-Slayer showed the people of Midgard a side of Thor they had not imagined. Thor’s connection with Jake Olson was a way to balance divinity and humanity in Thor but when they were separated that was lost. Amora, Thor Girl, Jake, and Thialfi each played a part in the change that came over Thor. Thor took Amora as his queen, pushing aside Sif as he had Balder. Thor planned to return to Asgard but Tarene and Jake asked him to stay and in that fateful moment, everything changed. Thor saw looters taking advantage of the chaos but whereas Avenger Thor would have stopped them and made them return their loot, King Thor saw humanity as a mob that needed to be tamed and controlled. So he called down a wind to scatter them and return to Asgard, bitterly expressing his disappointment. This visceral reaction drew forth the Spirit of the Jewel, creator of Desak, who knew he would be needed again someday so she took his body away to be healed and readied for his return as will Tarene and Zarrko. And the Spirit, who is an alternate version of Tarene, knows this is the moment of the birth and realization of the Designate….

Spidey and his Amazing Friends
Give that special marvelite a timely gift


Characters
Good (or All)
JAKEODUP  
Jake Olson
(duplicate)
THOR  
Thor
(Odinson)
THORGIRL  
Thor Girl
(Tarene)
Plus: Thialfi.

Antagonists
ENCHANTRESS  
GREYGARGOYLE  
Grey Gargoyle
(Paul Pierre Duval)
ZARRKO  
Zarrko
(Artur Zarrko)


Story #2

Forever Divided

Writer: Dan Jurgens.
Penciler: Deon Nuckols.
Inker: Jack Jadson.
Colorist: Avalon Studios.
Letterer: Richard Starkings.

Synopsis

By Peter Silvestro
Rating: 4 stars

As the women, accompanied by Lady Sif, await the return of the men from the war with the Frost Giants, Hyrra expresses much concern as her husband died in the battle against Surtur and she now fears for her son Osav who joined the conflict with the Frost Giants. When they see the men return, though fewer than went out, Hyrra rushes toward them to see Osav but she is stopped by Balder, conveying the worst possible news. Volstagg’s daughter rushes out to find her father and her husband both well. Sif asks Balder where Thor is and he restrains his anger to tell her his has gone to Midgard. Hyrra overhears this and pours out her grief and anger at Thor’s desertion of his people. Balder tries to explain the threat to Thor from Midgard but his listeners see this as just another excuse to be with the mortals; Thor is compared unfavorably to Odin, idealized in the minds of his subjects….

At the funerals, Loki approaches Hyrra at her son’s bier to convey his sympathies, while subtly undermining Thor’s authority. Elsewhere, Balder confides in Sif that he saw great doubt in the eyes of the warriors, even with Hogun, usually one of Thor’s staunchest defenders. The two are concerned about what this will mean for Thor’s rule. They are summoned to the main entry and learn that Thialfi was summoned by Amora to Thor’s aid, news that suggests even further chaos in the kingdom. The crowd in the main hall is hostile, demanding an audience with Thor who has still not returned. Balder tries to calm them but Loki comes to their defense. The aged warrior Ggorgstog, who has always supported Thor, pours out his and the others’ grievance and Balder can only agree with him. Thor, Amora, and Thialfi are listening to this from a balcony, unseen and Thor decides to seek council as to his response….

Thor goes to Olympus to throw himself at the feet of Zeus and lay out his lifelong dilemma of balancing his love of Asgard and concern for Midgard. Zeus notes that his son Hercules would have a similar dilemma should he ever rule. Having therefore thought about the issue, Zeus gives Thor an answer….

Back at the main hall of Asgard, Thor suddenly appears, admitting that his subjects have a right to be concerned. He defends his most recent action, leaving the battlefield to go to Midgard where Desak was the greatest threat. Thor apologizes to Hyrra, proclaiming that the people of Midgard need the rule and guidance of Asgard and so, as counseled by Zeus, they will now provide that guidance by taking direct rule over Earth. And so, Asgard appears over New York City….


Characters
Good (or All)
BALDER  
Balder
(The Brave)
SIF  
THOR  
Thor
(Odinson)
WARRIORS3  
Warriors Three
(Fandral, Hogun, Volstagg)
ZEUS  
Zeus
(Zeus Panhellenios)
Plus: Thialfi.

Antagonists
ENCHANTRESS  
LOKI  
Loki
(Loki Laufeyson)


Story #3

Children of the Gods

Writer: Jose H.P. Armenta.
Penciler: Joe Bennett.
Inker: Scott Hanna.
Colorist: Dave Kemp.
Letterer: Richard Starkings.

Synopsis

By Peter Silvestro
Rating: 4 stars

The young Thor spies a poor village where the people cry out for relief from hunger during a famine but the village elders complain that Odin has never come to their aid. Later, at a feast, Thor asks his father about the matter, wondering about injustice. Odin gives no answer save to rebuke him for disrespect. Thor storms off, heading to that village to end the drought and famine, and vanquish their enemies. Thor is hailed as a god and he promises them they will suffer no more. A woman demands that Thor bring her child back from the dead but he can’t. She spits in his face and runs off. Later, the men of the village come to Thor with a sacrifice to appease his anger: the corpse of the mother. Thor is shocked, calls them cowards and flees to Asgard. The men are insulted that Thor rejected their devotion and turn against the gods….

Thor goes to his father for comfort and the All-Father tells him mortals are like children and must learn and grow from their own mistakes….


Characters
Good (or All)
LOKI  
Loki
(Loki Laufeyson)
ODIN  
Odin
(All-Father)
THOR  
Thor
(Odinson)




> Thor (1998 series) comic book info and issue index



Marvel Premier Collection: Scarlet Witch Resin Statue
Give that special marvelite a timely gift

Previews

Click pages to see them in the Comic Viewer.

premium content


Main/1st Story Full Credits

Tom Raney
Scott Hanna
Avalon Studios
Tom Raney (Cover Penciler)
Scott Hanna (Cover Inker)
Dave Kemp (Cover Colorist)
Additional Credits
Letterer: Richard Starkings.
Editor: Tom Brevoort.



Review / Commentaries


reviewer
Thor (1998 series) #50 Review by (April 14, 2026)
Thor's 40th Anniversary issue. This issue includes the works by the winners of the Thor Creators contest: Deon Nuckols (pencils of the second story, "Forever Divided", his credits incorrectly stated in the issue as inks), and Jose H. P. Armenta (writer of the third story "Children of the Gods").

Additional Reviews and Comments by Peter Silvestro:

Review: The first story pretty much lays out all of where we’ve been and where we’re going, set up almost like a photo album, only with the omniscient narration of the Spirit of the Jewel. Raney and Hanna’s classy art recalls the medieval tapestry look of issue #45 though the way it’s presented feels like an information dump, explaining everything rather than showing it.

The second story puts a human face on the conflicts facing Thor, while exposing us to a new penciler who, it should be noted, never worked for Marvel again. Maybe it’s all the characters being too tall and thin. Maybe it’s the oddly shaped faces, never mind, the real meat of the story is Asgard’s rebellion against Thor and his wrongheaded solution to it. This bodes ill.

Third story is by a writer who won a contest and it’s a brief and bitter situation tragedy, teaching a lesson Thor should have remembered. Nicely put together, it’s a wonder that this author had no further work in the business.

Comments: Double-sized 40TH anniversary issue. issue includes the winners of the Thor Writing and Penciling contest. First story: Told in a series of full-page pictures with narration. Cameo by Heimdall. Second appearance of the Spirit of the Jewel, later revealed to be Tarene from Earth-3515; first was issue #48, she returns in issues #78-79.

Second story: Features the pencils of contest winner Deon Nuckols, who has a handful of credits for smaller presses, plus contributions to animation (see IMDb). The war with Surtur was in issues #39-40. Sole appearance of Hyrra. Ggorgstog was previously seen in issue #45, with a marked contrast to his attitude here.

Story three: Written by contest winner Jose H.P. Armenta, who has no further writing credits.






Thor

The Marvel Heroes Library is a fan Marvel Comics site
Version 14.14.10 (Apr 21, 2026 - VS22)

Copyright © 1997-2026 Julio Molina-Muscara (creator, webmaster)
Site content is a collective effort by the MHL team and Marvel aficionados

Characters are copyright © Marvel or their respective owners. All portions of this Marvel fansite that are subject to copyright are licensed under a creative commons attribution 3.0 unported license All rights reserved