Previous Page   Next Page
#1
#5
#17
#18
#27
#29
#33
#37
#61
#71
Selector

Marvel Graphic Novel #5

Chris Claremont | Brent Anderson

Marvel Graphic Novel #5 cover

Story Name:

God Loves, Man Kills


Synopsis

Marvel Graphic Novel #5 synopsis by Anthony Silvestro
Rating: 5 stars

In Westport, Connecticut, two young mutant children run for their lives, their parents having just been killed. Their pursuers, called the Purifiers, quickly catch up to them in a playground and callously gun the children down before displaying their dead bodies with the word “Muties” on the playground swings. All for the crime of being born mutants. Some time later, the children’s bodies are found by Magneto, who swears that no more shall die and that the ones responsible will pay! In New York City, fanatical Reverend William Stryker works on a sermon before reviewing briefing tapes on the X-Men and their powers, all while planning something sinister. We then cut to Stevie Hunter’s dance studio, where Kitty Pryde is in the middle of a fight with a boy named Danny. Colossus soon arrives to break up the fight and Stevie Hunter demands explanations from both. Danny said he supports the Stryker Crusade, who have plans to save humanity from mutants, which Kitty obviously took issue with, leading to the fight. Kitty runs off in frustration, while all the while the X-Men are being surveilled by the Purifiers.

Back at the mansion, the X-Men all sit down to watch a televised debate between Charles Xavier and Stryker. Stryker continues with his rhetoric of the dangers of mutants, rarely giving Xavier time to rebuff. After the debate, and Stryker’s ominous notions of treating mutants as if they aren’t human, the X-Men get ready for a Danger Room session to blow off steam, each with their own thoughts and worries. The X-Men are tasked with protecting a family of mannequins while transporting a large block to the other side of the room, each with their own individual goals. They complete their objective by switching goals and using teamwork to get the block to the other side and end the session. Meanwhile, in Central Park, the Purifiers attack Xavier’s car and he, Cyclops, and Storm are apparently killed! Back at the mansion, the X-Men are just finishing up their Danger Room session, when Nightcrawler answers the phone to hear that there was an accident and that Professor Xavier, Scott, and Ororo are dead!

The next day, Kitty sulks on the grounds of the mansion, being comforted by Illyana Rasputin, neither able to believe their friends are dead. As they walk the grounds, they find a strange sensor and Kitty phases through it, before hiding to see who comes to fix it. Meanwhile, the others investigate the site of the “accident.” Wolverine determines that it was only made to look like an accident and that the burned bodies that were found are not Xavier, Scott, and Ororo. They then spot the Purifiers watching in a car across the street and take them by surprise. The X-Men are then surprised themselves when two of the Purifiers reveal powerful mechsuits, but they are immediately dispatched with the arrival of Magneto, who announces he’s there as a friend and ally. Back at the mansion, another group of Purifiers arrive to fix the sensor they set up and Illyana is captured. Kitty attempts to tail them by phasing into the trunk of their car, but they release a dose of nerve gas into the trunk to knock out Kitty as well.

Just the Purifiers leave, Magneto and the X-Men return. Magneto tortures the Purifiers they captured for information and learns that they plan to use Xavier to bring about the extermination of mutants! Elsewhere, Xavier is plagued by visions of being crucified and tortured by the X-Men, revealed to be part of Stryker’s plan to break him, suspending Xavier in an isolation tank and drugging him in order to bend Xavier to his will. Cyclops and Storm, also being tortured, which feeds into Xavier’s visions, ask Stryker why he’s doing this. Stryker thinks back to thirty years previous, when he was an Army Sergeant. He and his pregnant wife were traveling when they got into an accident, and she was forced to give birth. Stryker was horrified at the appearance of his mutant son and killed both his newborn child and wife in shame. He attempted to kill himself too by putting them all in the car and lighting a match, but Stryker was blown clear of the car. After drifting for awhile in despair and anger, he came across an article on mutants written by Xavier and believed that mutants were the work of the devil and that it was his calling to save humanity from them, in the name of God.

After Stryker gives the order to kill Kitty, the Purifiers pull over but find that Kitty has escaped the trunk. Kitty runs but she finds herself in the midst of a street gang, where the head Purifier, Anne, quickly finds as well. Anne is forced to kill the gang, while Kitty slips away in the confusion, eventually able to find a phone to call the mansion. The Purifiers chase Kitty onto the El train and shoot a cop who tries to protect her. The train suddenly lifts into the air, signaling the arrival of Magneto, while the other X-Men quickly deal with the Purifiers. Meanwhile, Stryker’s brainwashing of Xavier appears to be complete when Xavier apparently kills Cyclops and Storm after an order from Stryker. Not long after, Kitty captures Dr. Ramsey, the man who was overseeing Xavier’s brainwashing and Nightcrawler intimidates the man for information. Some time later, Scott and Ororo’s bodies, along with Illyana, are loaded into an elevator at the Stryker building, before Magneto lifts the entire elevator out of the building, while Stryker’s right-hand woman Anne narrowly manages to escape. Wolverine determines that Scott and Ororo aren’t dead and Magneto revives them, determining that Charles must have unconsciously held back and merely put them in stasis.

Later that night, Stryker makes the final preparations for the big sermon he’s giving at Madison Square Garden. Stryker sets up Xavier to scan for all nearby mutants and kill them when he makes contact with them. Stryker begins his sermon, detailing that any deviation from how God made humanity, i.e mutants, is of the devil and needs to be exterminated for the good of the future of mankind. Meanwhile, Xavier’s mindscan is put into action with the X-Men and all other nearby mutants feeling the effects. Magneto arrives to confront Stryker directly and Stryker turns Xavier’s power directly at Magneto full force. It knocks Magneto for a loop, making him realize just how much Xavier had been holding back before, as Magneto is barely able to keep the angry crowd back. The police and many of the spectators are beginning to see the insane extent of Stryker’s views. While Magneto confronts Stryker directly, the X-Men sneak in the back and deal with the Purifiers in an attempt to get to Xavier.

Anne runs to warn Stryker, when she suddenly feels the effects of Xavier’s scan, revealing that she’s unknowingly a mutant as well! Stryker rebukes her and pushes her from the stage, where she falls to her death, all caught on live TV. Backstage, the X-Men pull a clever move to incapacitate Xavier. Nightcrawler teleports with Wolverine right behind Xavier, who blasts them away, while Cyclops ricochets his beam off of multiple surfaces to nail the distracted Xavier. Though they seem to have won, the X-Men instead head onstage to confront Stryker directly. Cyclops debates with Stryker, saying that they’re just as human as everyone else, regardless of what they can do. Stryker points to Nightcrawler, indignant that they would dare call him human and Kitty fires back, saying he’s one of the kindest, most human people she knows and that she’ll stand with him over believing in Stryker’s supposed God. Stryker pulls a gun on the X-Men but before he can fire, he’s shot by one of the cops and taken into custody.

Back at the mansion, Xavier feels lost and despondent over everything that happened, nearly ready to agree to Magneto’s more violent methods for his mutant utopia. Cyclops steps up and convinces Xavier to take up his dream once more. Even though it will be hard, the means are just as important as the ends, built on the hope of a better world. Xavier once again rejects Magneto’s offer, to his disappointment. Kitty offers Magneto to join their cause, but he declines, not able to fight for something he doesn’t believe in. Magneto departs, genuinely hoping the X-Men’s way succeeds, but if it doesn’t, then it’ll be his turn. Xavier is overcome with gratitude at Scott’s empowering words, and Storm echoes the sentiment, proud at how Scott handled both confronting Stryker and convincing Xavier that his dream was still good. Scott just says that he helped someone in need, which is what it’s all really about, what makes the world go ‘round. So they’ll continue to fight for a world where that’s so.


Characters
Good (or All)
COLOSSUS
CYCLOPS
KPRYDE
MAGIK
MAGNETO
NIGHTCRAWLER
XAVIER
STORM
WOLVERINE
XMEN
Plus: Stevie Hunter.

Enemies
Purifiers, William Stryker.

> Marvel Graphic Novel comic book info and issue index



Excelsioring your collection:
statue
Holy smokes, Batman!
(The Boy Wonder)

Main/1st Story Full Credits

Brent Anderson
Brent Anderson
Steve Oliff
Brent Anderson (Cover Penciler)
Brent Anderson (Cover Inker)
Brent Anderson (Cover Colorist)
Additional Credits
Letterer: Tom Orzechowski.



Review / Commentaries


Marvel Graphic Novel #5 Review by (December 26, 2024)

Review: The social and political aspects of the X-Men are at their most overt as an evangelical preacher hunts the X-Men in the name of God, simply for being mutants! This is pretty much the quintessential X-Men story, really delving into the heart of what the franchise is all about, albeit with a much harsher and darker tone than usual. It’s so iconic, it was used as the primary inspiration for X-Men 2. The panel of Stryker saying “you dare call that thing human” about Nightcrawler is particularly well-known and really drives the point home. This story is sometimes accused of being inherently anti-Christian or anti-God but I disagree. After all, Nightcrawler and Kitty are both shown to believe in God, so Claremont likely isn’t totally against the idea. I think it’s more presenting the dangers of those who use God as an excuse for their own agendas and fanaticism. To me, the one cop’s words, “if that’s the word of God, it’s sure changed some since Sunday School”, really drives that idea home.

What’s interesting is that this comic was originally considered to be non-canon, with its canonicity only being established years later. As such, there are little oddities such as this being the only time Kitty ever uses the Ariel codename. It’s also interesting that since this story is now considered canon, this is the next time we’ve seen Magneto chronologically since UXM #150. It’s cool that it then follows the idea of his potential redemption by working with the X-Men and not really considering them enemies. He does reaffirm his ideals of a utopia safe for mutants, no matter the cost and though he and the X-Men remain on opposite sides at the end idealistically, Magneto does admit that he hopes their way succeeds, for the good of all. Only if it doesn’t, will it be his turn. It’s the first time Magneto has expressed an amount of respect and hope for Xavier’s viewpoint. This story is also extremely well-paced for a 65-page story, with practically every scene being memorable and important, with beautiful art by Brent Anderson that looks almost painted. Overall, one of the best X-Men stories, with hard-hitting themes that get at the core of the franchise and bring the not-so-subtle social allegory of mutants to the forefront.

Comments: This was originally considered a non-canon story, with its canonicity only decided upon years later. This is the only time Kitty uses the Ariel codename.





Thor

The Marvel Heroes Library is a fan Marvel Comics site
Version 14.8.58 (Jan 24, 2025 - VS22)

Copyright © 1997-2025 Julio Molina-Muscara (creator, webmaster)
Site content is a collective effort by the MHL team and Marvel aficionados

Characters are copyright © Marvel or their respective owners. All portions of this Marvel fansite that are subject to copyright are licensed under a creative commons attribution 3.0 unported license All rights reserved