Comic Browser:

#45
#46
#47
#48
#49
#50
#52
#54
#55
#56
#57
#58
Selector

Silver Surfer #58: Review

Nov 1991
Ron Marz, Todd Smith

Story Name:

Forgiveness

Review & Comments

Rating:
4 stars

Silver Surfer #58 Review by (April 30, 2021)
This is another tie-in to the Infinity Gauntlet event, continuing a 2-parter from last issue.

This time Ron Lim is completely replaced by another penciller Todd Smith. (Well, Ron's IG issues need a lot of pencilling.)

We never do find out who Virtual Reality might be (if it's not Jim Starlin).

Silver Surfer returns to reality just in time to join Adam Warlock for the start of IG#5.

The mystery char at the end of this issue will inhabit the last page of next issue too, and turn out in #60 to be the Collector.





 

Synopsis / Summary / Plot

Silver Surfer #58 Synopsis by Rob Johnson
Last issue Thanos sent Silver Surfer into a strange realm which a being named Virtual Reality called the Hall Of Absolutes. VR accompanied him as he was shown the memories from his past that stood out in his mind. And then all was black. Now VR leaves him saying that it was his own memories that led him here, now he must find his own way back.

Surfer uses his Power Cosmic to shatter his way through a wall, but that just gets him into a corridor. He provides his own light and begins to explore. After various dead ends he at last enters a room with 3 more doorways in front of him. And out of them walk what seem to be his fellow Defenders Dr Strange, Hulk and Sub-Mariner complaining that he deserted them. But Norrin Radd doesn't understand because Hulk and Subby were killed by Thanos (Infinity Gauntlet #4) and Strange is on Earth monitoring the battle (IG#3).

Whatever, they attack him and tell him to admit his errors. SS says he's tried to atone for his past misdeeds (mainly helping Galactus eat inhabited planets) and blasts back at them. Then they rip off their faces to reveal ghoulish cadavers who claim to be Denial, Doubt and Guilt. And he will never be free of them.

VR returns and Surfer finds himself shackled. He says that the chains are created by his denial, doubt and guilt. And Norrin must free *himself*. So saying he and the 3 ghouls leave with the cryptic remark "Search (within) yourself for the answer".

Surfer strains against his bonds to no avail. Then his dead mother appears. (As with the Defenders we are seeing the elements of his past from last issue.) He says he thought it was his fault that she committed suicide when he was a boy. But she tells him it was just between her and his father, and she produces a key and unlocks 1 of his chains. His equally-suicidal father appears next. Norrin also blames himself for that (with some justification, see #50) but daddy uses another key. The 3rd visitor is Shalla-Bal and she forgives him for pushing her away and leaving her. There goes another lock. His lovers Mantis and Nova (Frankie Raye) are last to forgive him. And Mantis confides that she didn't really die (#9).

But there's 1 chain left and no more 'ghosts' to visit him (unless Thanos counts). He realises that the only 1 left to forgive him is himself. He reaches inside his chest and extracts a last key, and he's free.

Then he finds himself with Virtual Reality again in the Hall Of Absolutes. But it is no longer stark black and white because he's learned to see in shades of grey. Now that his trial is over VR sends him back to reality, and he arrives on his board once more near Adam Warlock floating in space.

But like last issue we end with 1 more unconnected page. This time we see a spaceship crashed in the Blue Area Of The Moon. And someone stumbles from it who had been left for dead.



Todd Smith
Tom Christopher
Tom Vincent
Ron Lim (Cover Penciler)
Tom Christopher (Cover Inker)
? (Cover Colorist)
Letterer: Ken Bruzenak.
Editor: Craig Anderson. Editor-in-chief: Tom DeFalco.

Characters

Listed in Alphabetical Order.

> Silver Surfer: Book info and issue index

Share This Page


Elektra